The need for protection of environmental defenders from digital intimidation: an analysis of Article 3(8) of the Aarhus Convention
Lien Stolle
University of GhentAbstract
Digital technologies are becoming increasingly important to environmental defenders,
both in terms of tools that facilitate speaking out and/or taking action, and in terms
of (digital) risks they face as a result of their involvement. A growing concern has been
expressed about the use of various forms of online and technology-facilitated intimidation
or “digital intimidation” against environmental defenders. While the existing research on
cyberbullying, digital violence and online intimidation can provide some insight, few studies
and data exist on the use of such tactics against environmental defenders in particular.
By leaving this issue unexamined, there remains a lack of awareness about the risks and
challenges environmental defenders may face in terms of online safety and digital intimidation,
which may ultimately curtail public debate on environmental issues. Fortunately, the
protections under Article 3(8) of the Aarhus Convention and the recently introduced Special
Rapporteur for Environmental Defenders can be useful in providing protection against
digital intimidation. This paper, therefore, looks at the application of Article 3(8) to digital
intimidation, through the decisions of the Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee, and
also considers the mandate given to the Special Rapporteur at the 2020 Meeting of the
Parties. The analysis shows that there is certainly potential for protection against digital intimidation
under Article 3(8) AC, but more explicit attention and awareness may be needed.
Keywords:
Environmental defenders, Aarhus Convention, Digital harassmentReferences
Council of Europe Recommendation 2016: Recommendation CM/Rec(2016)4 of the Committee of Ministers to member States on the protection of journalism and safety of journalists and other media actors.
Google Scholar
Directive 2003/35/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 May 2003 providing for public participation in respect of the drawing up of certain plans and programmes relating to the environment and amending with regard to public participation
Google Scholar
and access to justice Council Directives 85/337/EEC and 96/61/EC, CONSIL, EP, 156 OJ L (2003).
Google Scholar
The UNECE Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in Decision-making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters (Aarhus Convention) (1998).
Google Scholar
Directive 2003/4/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 28 January 2003 on public access to environmental information and repealing Council Directive 90/313/EEC, CONSIL, EP, 041 OJ L (2003).
Google Scholar
ECtHR, Khadija Ismayilova c. Azerbaïdjan, Nr. 65286/13, 57270/14 (10 January 2019).
Google Scholar
ECtHR, Volodina c. Russie (n° 2), Nr. 40419/19 (14 September 2021).
Google Scholar
Findings and recommendations Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee of 7 June 2021, ACCC/C/2013/98 Lithuania, ECE/MP.PP/C.1/2021/15.
Google Scholar
Findings and recommendations Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee of 18 June 2010, ACCC/C/2009/36 Spain, ECE/MP.PP/C.1/2010/4/Add.2.
Google Scholar
Findings and recommendations Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee of 17 December 2010, ACCC/C/2009/43 Armenia, ECE/MP.PP/2011/11/Add.1.
Google Scholar
Findings and recommendations Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee of 18 June 2017, ACCC/C/2014/102 Belarus, ECE/MP.PP/C.1/2017/19.
Google Scholar
Recommendations Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee of 1 July 2020, ACCC/A/2020/2 Kazakhstan, ECE/MP.PP/C.1/2021/6.
Google Scholar
Article 19. 2020. Investigating online harassment and abuse of women journalists. Article 19. https://www.article19.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Gender-Paper-Brief-3-.pdf.
Google Scholar
Barker, Kim, and Olga Jurasz. 2019. Online Misogyny as Hate Crime A Challenge for Legal Regulation? Taylor & Francis. DOI: 10.4324/9780429956805.
Google Scholar
Barker, Kim, and Olga Jurasz. 2022. Violence Against Women, Hate and Law: Perspectives from Contemporary Scotland. Springer International Publishing. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-030-99375-7.
Google Scholar
Belga 2020. Actie klimaatactivisten op Autosalon krijgt juridisch staartje. VRT, https://www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2020/01/21/actie-klimaatactivisten-op-autosalon-krijgt-juridisch-staartje/.
Google Scholar
Belga and HL. 2020. Extinction Rebellion verstoort Autosalon: al zeker 185 actievoerders opgepakt. De Morgen, https://www.demorgen.be/nieuws/extinction-rebellion-verstoort-autosalon-al-zeker-185-actievoerders-opgepakt~b2d5693b/.
Google Scholar
Barritt, Emily. 2021. Foundations of the Aarhus convention: Environmental democracy, rights and stewardship. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
Google Scholar
Bille Larsen, Peter, Phillipe Le Billon, Mary Menton, Jose Aylwin, Jorg Balsiger, David Boyd, Michel Forst, Fran Lambrick, Claudelice Santos, Hannah Storey, and Susan Wilding. 2021. Understanding and responding to the environmental human rights
Google Scholar
defenders crisis: The case for conservation action. Conservation Letters 14(3): e12777. DOI: 10.1111/conl.12777.
Google Scholar
Boren, Zach, and Damian Kahya. 2019. German far right targets Greta Thunberg in anti-climate push. Unearthed, https://unearthed.greenpeace.org/2019/05/14/germany-climate- denial-populist-eike-afd/.
Google Scholar
Butt, Natalie, Frances Lambrick, Mary Menton, and Anna Renwick. 2019. The supply chain of violence. Nature Sustainability, 2(8): 742-747. DOI: 10.1038/s41893-019-0349-4.
Google Scholar
Dunn, Suzie. 2020. Technology-facilitated gender-based violence: An overview. Centre for International Governance Innovation. Supporting a Safer Internet Paper 1, https://www.cigionline.org/static/documents/documents/SaferInternet_Paper%20no%201_0.pdf.
Google Scholar
Eklöw, Karolina, and José Francisco Alvarado Cóbar. 2021. Surveillance as slow violence: Experiences from young environmental activists. SIPRI, https://www.sipri.org/commentary/ blog/2021/surveillance-slow-violence-experiences-young-environmental-activists.
Google Scholar
Ferrier, Michelle, and Nisha Garud-Patkar. 2018. Trollbusters: Fighting online harassment of women Journalists. Mediating Misogyny: Gender, Technology, and Harassment, (eds.)
Google Scholar
Jacqueline Ryan Vickery, Tracy Everbach, 311–332. Springer International Publishing. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-72917-6_16.
Google Scholar
Front Line Defenders. 2021. Front Line Defenders Global Analysis 2020. https://www.frontlinedefenders. org/sites/default/files/fld_global_analysis_2020.pdf.
Google Scholar
Front Line Defenders. 2022. Front Line Defenders Global Analysis 2021. https://www.frontlinedefenders.org/sites/default/files/2021_global_analysis_-_final.pdf.
Google Scholar
George, Jordana, and Dorothy E. Leidner. 2019. From clicktivism to hacktivism: Understanding digital activism. Information and Organization 29(3): 100249. DOI: 10.1016/j. infoandorg.2019.04.001.
Google Scholar
Global Witness. 2021. Annual report 2021: Our case for change, https://www.globalwitness.org/en/about-us/global-witness-annual-reports/.
Google Scholar
GREVIO Recommendation. 2021. General Recommendation No. 1 on the digital dimension of violence against women, https://rm.coe.int/grevio-rec-no-on-digital-violence-againstwomen/1680a49147.
Google Scholar
Karagiannopoulos, Vasileos. 2018. Looking into the positive and negative aspects of hacktivism.Living With Hacktivism: From Conflict to Symbiosis, (ed.) V Vasileos Karagiannopoulos, 43-90. Springer International Publishing. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-71758-6_3.
Google Scholar
Kleemola, Katie, Masashi Crete-Nishihata, Adam Senft, and Irene Poetranto. 2015. Targeted malware attacks against NGO linked to attacks on Burmese government websites.
Google Scholar
Citizen Lab Research Report – University of Toronto 65, https://citizenlab.ca/2015/10/targeted-attacks-ngo-burma/.
Google Scholar
Lewis, Seth C., Rodrigo Zamith, and Mark Coddington. 2020. Online harassment and its
Google Scholar
implications for the journalist – audience relationship. Digital Journalism 8(8): 1047-1067. DOI: 10.1080/21670811.2020.1811743.
Google Scholar
Lloro, Teresa. 2018. An ecofeminist account of cyberbullying: Implications for environmental
Google Scholar
and social justice scholar-educator-activists. The Journal of Environmental Education 49: 1-10. DOI: 10.1080/00958964.2017.1400513.
Google Scholar
Lomba, Niombo, Cecilia Navarra, and Meenakshi Fernandes. 2021. Combating gender-based violence: Cyber violence. Think Tank. European Parliament (PE 662.621). European Parliamentary Research Service (EPRS).
Google Scholar
Macpherson, Aida. 2021. (Not) Part of the Job: Een exploratief onderzoek naar de ervaringen van gekleurde vrouwelijke journalisten en opiniemakers in Vlaanderen en Brussel met online intimidatie. De Vlaamse ScripteBank. KU Leuven Publicaties, https://www.
Google Scholar
scriptiebank.be/scriptie/2021/not-part-job-een-exploratief-onderzoek-naar-de-ervaringen-van-gekleurde-vrouwelijke.
Google Scholar
McCully, Jonathan, and Scot Griffen. 2019. Legal Responses to Online Harassment and Abuse of Journalists: Perspectives from Finland, France and Ireland. OSCE.
Google Scholar
Nadim, Marjan, and Audun Fladmoe. 2021. Silencing women? Gender and online harassment. Social Science Computer Review 39(2): 245-258. DOI: 10.1177/0894439319865518.
Google Scholar
Nevett, Joshua. 2019. Greta Thunberg: Why are young climate activists facing so much hate? BBC News, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-49291464.
Google Scholar
Nixon, Rob. 2013. Slow Violence and the Environmentalism of the Poor. Harvard University Press.
Google Scholar
Nogrady, Bianca. 2021. ‘I hope you die’: How the COVID pandemic unleashed attacks on scientists. Nature 598: 250-253. DOI: 10.1038/d41586-021-02741-x.
Google Scholar
Nogrady, Bianca. 2022. Online harassment: A toolkit for protecting yourself from abuse. Nature 609: 205-207. DOI: 10.1038/d41586-022-02766-w.
Google Scholar
O’Malley, G. 2013. Hacktivism: Cyber activism or cyber crime. Trinity College Law Review 16: 137.
Google Scholar
Pen America. 2018. Defining “Online Abuse”: A Glossary of Terms. Online Harassment
Google Scholar
Field Manual. https://onlineharassmentfieldmanual.pen.org/defining-online-harassmenta- glossary-of-terms/.
Google Scholar
Poetranto, I., S. Chan, and S. Anstis. (2020). ON/OFFLINE: Multidimensional threats faced by environmental human rights defenders in Southeast Asia. Global Information Society Watch 2020 – Technology, the Environment and a Sustainable World: Responses from the Global South, (eds.) A. Finlay, L. Nordstorm, 72-77. Association for Progressive Communications and Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency.
Google Scholar
Press Release UN Special Rapporteur on Environmental Defenders. 2022. UN Special Rapporteur on Environmental Defenders presents his vision for mandate to ensure protection under the Aarhus Convention. https://unece.org/climate-change/press/un-special-rapporteur- environmental-defenders-presents-his-vision-mandate.
Google Scholar
Romagna, Marco. 2020. Hacktivism: Conceptualization, techniques, and historical view.
Google Scholar
The Palgrave handbook of international cybercrime and cyberdeviance, 743-769. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-78440-3_34.
Google Scholar
Scheidel, Arnim, Daniela Del Bene, Juan Liu, Grettel Navas, Sara Mingorría, Federico Demaria,
Google Scholar
Sofía Avila, Brototi Roy, Irmak Ertör, Leah Temper, and Joan Martínez-Alier. 2020. Environmental conflicts and defenders: A global overview. Global Environmental Change, 63: 102104. DOI: 0.1016/j.gloenvcha.2020.102104.
Google Scholar
Siatisa, I. 2021. Freedom of assembly under attack: General and indiscriminate surveillance and interference with internet communications. International Review of the Red Cross. http:// international-review.icrc.org/articles/freedom-assembly-under-attack-surveillance-interference-internet-communications-913.
Google Scholar
Smith, K. 2019. The Harassment of Environmental Defenders in the European Union: a case study report. EEB, https://eeb.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/The-Harassment-of-Environmental-Defenders-in-the-European-Union-%E2%80%93-A-Case-Study-Report.pdf.
Google Scholar
Smith, Peter J., and Elizabeth Smythe. 1999. Globalization, citizenship and technology: The mai meets the internet. Canadian Foreign Policy Journal 7(2): 83-105. DOI: 10.1080/11926422.1999.9673213.
Google Scholar
Swedish Society for Nature Conservation. 2019. Environmental Report defenders under attack: The threats facing people who protect nature. Swedish Society for Nature Conservation, https://www.naturskyddsforeningen.se/artiklar/report-environmental-defenders-
Google Scholar
under-attack-the-threats-facing-people-who-protect-nature/.
Google Scholar
UN General Assembly. 2016. Situation of human rights defenders (A/71/281).
Google Scholar
UN Human Rights Council. 2018. Report of the Special Rapporteur on violence against women, its causes and consequences on online violence against women and girls from a human rights perspective (A/HRC/38/47).
Google Scholar
UNECE. 2014. The Aarhus Convention: An implementation guide (Second edition).
Google Scholar
UNECE. 2019. Guide to the Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee, https://unece.org/
Google Scholar
info/Environment-Policy/Public-participation/pub/2291.
Google Scholar
UNECE. 2021. Decision VII/9 on a Rapid Response Mechanism to Deal with Cases Related to Article 3 (8) of the Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in Decision-making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters’. UN Doc ECE/
Google Scholar
MP.PP/2021/CRP.8, https://unece.org/sites/default/files/2021-11/ECE.MP_.PP_.2021_ RRM_CRP.8_3.pdf
Google Scholar
van der Wilk, Adriane. 2018. Cyber violence and hate speech online against women. European Parliament’s Committee on Women’s Rights and Gender Equality. DOI: 10.2861/738618.
Google Scholar
Verweijen, Judith, Fran Lambrick, Philippe Le Billon, Felipe Milanez, Ansumana Manneh and Melisa Moreano Venegas. 2021. “Environmental defenders”: The power/disempowerment of a loaded term. Environmental and Land Defenders: Deadly Struggles for Life and Territory, (eds.) Mary Menton and Philippe Le Billion, 37-49. Routledge.
Google Scholar
Vogels, E.A. 2021. The State of Online Harassment. Pew Research Center, https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2021/01/13/the-state-of-online-harassment/.
Google Scholar
Weber, Teresa. 2022. Are climate activists protected by the Aarhus Convention? A note on Article 3(8) Aarhus Convention and the new Rapid Response Mechanism for environmental defenders. Review of European, Comparative & International Environmental Law. DOI: 10.1111/reel.12465.
Google Scholar
Winkelman, Sloane Burke, Jody Oomen Early, Ashley D. Walker, Lawrence Chu, and Alice Yick-Flanagan. 2015. Exploring cyber harrassment among women who use social media. Universal Journal of Public Health 3(5): 194-201. DOI: 10.13189/ujph.2015.030504.
Google Scholar
Authors
Lien StolleStatistics
Downloads
License
Copyright (c) 2023 The Opole Studies in Administration and Law
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Author’s economic rights to published works are held by Opole University (collective works) and individual Authors (individual parts of the collective work, ones that form a separate entity).
The journal Opole Studies in Administration and Law accepts for publication only works which have not been in circulation before.
On the basis of the Regulation (2016/679) of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, and repealing Directive 95/46/EC (referred to as General Data Protection Regulation or RODO) Opole University, based at 11a Plac Kopernika, 45-040 Opole, is the personal data controller for all the authors publishing their works in the Opole Studies in Administration and Law.
The articles published in Opole Studies in Administration and Law are available under a licence Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
For aricles till 2017 your use is permitted by an applicable exception or limitation – see:
Ustawa z dnia 4 lutego 1994 r. o prawie autorskim i prawach pokrewnych
Read more about the license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
View Legal Code:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/legalcode
