The substantive right to environment and the procedural environmental rights under the Aarhus Convention – Part I

Jerzy Jendrośka

doi:10.25167/osap.5404

Published: 2024-01-16

Vol. 21 No. 2 (2023)

The substantive right to environment and the procedural environmental rights under the Aarhus Convention – Part I

Jerzy Jendrośka

The Opole Studies in Administration and Law

Section: Articles

https://doi.org/10.25167/osap.5404

Abstract

The current article provides Part I of the article which aims at examining the mutual relations between substantive and procedural environmental rights against the background of the typology of the substantive rights to the environment and challenges encountered when designing the right to a healthy environment. Part I provides the background analysis in this respect. It presents the origins of the term “right to environment” and various approaches to its meaning, in particular differences between the “right to have access to natural environment” and the “right to a healthy environment”. This is followed by presenting two possible approaches to the meaning of the term “right to a healthy environment” and their consequences. On this basis the article shows the three main methods of addressing concerns regarding environmental quality within human rights system and the relation between anthropocentric and ecocentric approach. Following this, the article presents the main challenges encountered when creating “right to a healthy environment”, in particular the issue of fitting this right into the existing system of protecting human rights and limitations related to “greening” of other human rights. Finally the current article provides a short overview of the the development of the respective legal provisions regarding environmental rights, including both human rights and Rights of Nature. Part I is concluded with some comments regarding the trend towards developing procedural environmental rights and expectations towards the UNECE Aarhus Convention and its role in protecting substantive environmental rights and participatory democracy – which is the link to Part II which addresses these issues in detail and concludes that access to justice provisions under the Aarhus Convention neither provide sufficient means to protect environmental rights nor – in light of the various conceptual roots of the Convention - should be treated as having only such a role.

Most read articles by the same author(s)

Jerzy Jendrośka, Moritz REESE, Lorenzo SQUINTANI, Towards a new legal framework for sustainability under the European Green Deal , The Opole Studies in Administration and Law: Vol. 19 No. 2 (2021)
Magdalena Bar, Jerzy Jendrośka, Dr Jan Jerzmański (1957-2021) , The Opole Studies in Administration and Law: Vol. 19 No. 2 (2021)
Jerzy Jendrośka, The substantive right to environment and the procedural environmental rights under the Aarhus Convention – Part II , The Opole Studies in Administration and Law: Vol. 22 No. 2 (2024): The Opole Studies in Administration and Law

Download files

PDF

Citation rules

Jendrośka, J. (2024). The substantive right to environment and the procedural environmental rights under the Aarhus Convention – Part I. The Opole Studies in Administration and Law, 21(2), 141–169. https://doi.org/10.25167/osap.5404

Cited by / Share

Licence

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

References

CEP Report 1996 - The report of the special session 17 January 1996 ece/cep/18, Annex I
Google Scholar

Draft elements for the convention on access to environmental information and public participation in environmental decision-making (cep/ac.3/R.1) available at http://www.unece.org/env/pp/adwg.html
Google Scholar

European Governance. A White Paper, COM(2001) 428, available at https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/DOC_01_10
Google Scholar

Individualrecht oder Verpflichtung des Staates?Jnternationales Beitrage zum Umweltgestaltung, Heft A-41, E.Schmidt Verlag Berlin 1976QA
Google Scholar

Case X v. Federal Republic of Germany (dec) no 7407/76 , 13.5. 1976
Google Scholar

Case López Ostra v. Spain judgment of 9 December 1994, Series A no. 303-C, para 51
Google Scholar

Hatton Case Hatton and others v. the United Kingdom [GC], no 36022/97, 8.7.2003, para 96
Google Scholar

ECtHR judgment of 22.5.2003, 41666/98, Kyrtatos v. Greece
Google Scholar

ACCC/C/2008/31, Germany, ECE/MP.PP/C.1/2014/8, para. 94
Google Scholar

Bandi, Guyla, 2014, Right to Environment – Procedural Guarantees. In: Environmental Democracy and Law, G.Bandi (ed.) , Europa Law 2014,
Google Scholar

Aarhus Implementation Guide 2000 - S. Stec, S. and S. Casey-Lefkowitz, with J. Jendrośka, The Aarhus Convention: An Implementation Guide, United Nations, 1st ed., 2000
Google Scholar

Aarhus Implementation Guide 2014 -J. Ebbesson, H. Gaugitsch, J.Jendrośka, S. Stec and F. Marshall, The Aarhus Convention. An Implementation Guide, second edition, United Nations 2014,
Google Scholar

Barrit, Emily, 2020, The Foundations of the Aarhus Convention, Hart Publishing 2020 DOI: https://doi.org/10.5040/9781509915293
Google Scholar

Betaille, Julien, 2019, Rights of Nature: Why it Might Not Save the Entire World’, Journal for European Environmental and Planning Law 16 (2019) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/18760104-01601004
Google Scholar

Boyd, David, 2020, Introductory presentation to the Hight-level Conference on Environmental Protection and Human Rights, Council of Europe, 27 II 2020
Google Scholar

Boyle, Allan, 2006, Human Rights or Environmental Rights? A Reassessment, Fordham Environmental Law Review, Vol. 18 No 3, 2006.
Google Scholar

Brady, Kathy, 1998, New Convention on Access to Information and Public Participation in Environmental Matters, Environmental Policy and Law, 28/(1998
Google Scholar

Burdon, Peter and Williams,Claire, 2022, Rights of nature: a critique. In: Research Handbook of Fundamental Concepts of Environmental Law, D. Fisher (ed), Edward Elgar, 2nd. ed. 2022,
Google Scholar

Calderon Gamboa, Jorge, 2020, Inter-American approaches to the right to a healthy environment and the rights of nature. In: Human Rights for the Planet, Proceedings of the High-Level International Conference on Human Rights and Environmental Protection , Strasbourg, 5 October 2020
Google Scholar

Carducci et al, 2019, Towards an EU Charter of the Fundamental Rights of Nature, European Economic and Social Committee, available at: https://www.eesc.europa.eu/en/our-work/publications-other-work/publications/towards-eu-charter-fundamental-rights-nature
Google Scholar

de Sadeleer, Nicolas, 2012, Enforcing EUCHR Principles and Fundamental Rights in Environmental Cases, Nordic Journal of International Law 2012, Nr 81 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/157181011X618758
Google Scholar

de Sadeleer Nicolas, Roller Gerhard and Dross Miriam, 2005 , Access to justice in environmental matters and the role of ngos; empirical findings and legal appraisal, 1st ed. Groningen (Europa LawPublishing) 2005
Google Scholar

du Plessis, Willemien, 2012, The balance of sustainability interests from the perspective of the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights. In :M. Faure, W. du Plessis (eds.), The balancing of interests in environmental law in Africa, Pretoria, 2012
Google Scholar

Eckel, Jan and Moyn, Samuel , 2014, The Breakthrough: Human Rights in the 1970s, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2014, DOI: https://doi.org/10.9783/9780812208719
Google Scholar

Darpo, Jan 2021, Can Nature Get it Right. A Study on Rights of Nature in the European Context, European Parliament,2021 (available at http://www.europarl.europa.
Google Scholar

eu/supporting-analyses)
Google Scholar

Epstein Yaffa and Schoukens, Hendrik, 2021, A Positivist Approach to Rights of Nature in the European Union. Journal of Human Rights and the Environment. (2021).12. 1 DOI: https://doi.org/10.4337/jhre.2021.02.03
Google Scholar

Ermacora, Florian, 2003, The Right to a Clean Environment in the Constitution of the European Union. In: The European Convention and the Future of European Environmental Law, J Jans (ed.), Groningen, 2003,
Google Scholar

Giunta, Adriana, 2017, Can an Ecocentric Approach Open New Frontiers for a Legally Binding International Environmental Right? A Study of Norway’s Environmental Constitutional Right (in:) New Frontiers in Environmental Constitutionalism, UNEP 2017,
Google Scholar

Gormley, Paul, 1976, Human Rights and Environment - the Need for International Co-operation, Leyden 1976,
Google Scholar

Grand, Ewadne, 2017, Judicial implementation of rights based approaches to environmental governance: Regional perspectives. In: New Frontiers in Environmental Constitutionalism, UNEP 2017
Google Scholar

Hernekamp, Karl, 1979, Soziale Grundrechte, Aktuelle Dokumente, ed, K. Hernekamp, Berlin-New York, 1979 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110888713
Google Scholar

Habuda, Adam, 2019,The right to the Environment in the Republic of Poland, Studia Prawnoustrojowe UWM no 44,
Google Scholar

Hallo, 1996, Ralph , Access to environmental information in Europe, Kluver 1996
Google Scholar

Jendrośka, Jerzy, 1990, Z rozważań nad znaczeniem pojęcia „obywatelskie prawo do środowiska” Acta Universitatis Wratislaviensis, Prawo CLXVIII, 1990, s. 93-101 (Thoughts on the meaning of „citizens right to environment”), Acta Universitatis Wratislaviensis, Prawo CLXVIII, 1990,
Google Scholar

Jendrośka, Jerzy, 2005-1, Aarhus Convention and Community Law: the Interplay (in:) Journal for European Environmental & Planning Law, 1/2005, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/187601005X00570
Google Scholar

Jendrośka, Jerzy 2005-2, Public Information and Participation in EC Environmental Law; Origins, Milestones and Trends. In: Reflections on 30 Years of EU Environmental Law; A High Level of Protection?, R. Macrory (ed.), Europa Law Publishing, Groningen, 2005
Google Scholar

Jendrośka, Jerzy, 2012. Citizen’s Rights in European Environmental Law: Stock-Taking of Key Challenges and Current Developments in Relation to Public Access to Information, Participation and Access to Justice, Journal for European Environmental & Planning Law Vol. 9 (2012) No. 1 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/187601012X632265
Google Scholar

Jendrośka, Jerzy, 2020-1 , Access to Justice in the Aarhus Convention – Genesis, Legislative History and Overview of the Main Interpretation Dilemmas, Journal for European Environmental & Planning Law Vol. 17 (2020) , DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/18760104-01704003
Google Scholar

Jendrośka Jerzy and Anapianova Alina, 2023, Towards a Green Energy Transition: REPowerEU Directive vs Environmental Acquis., ELNI Review 2023, Vol 23 available at https://doi.org/10.46850/elni.2023.001 DOI: https://doi.org/10.46850/elni.2023.001
Google Scholar

Jendrośka, Jerzy and Longi, Maria, 1998, Environmental Protection and the New Polish Constitution, ELNI Newsletter, No2/1998,
Google Scholar

Jendrośka, Jerzy and Stec, Stephen, 2001, The Aarhus Convention: Towards a New Era in Environmental Democracy, Environmental Liability, (2001) Vol 9, Issue 3
Google Scholar

Knox John, 2017, The United Nations Mandate on Human Rights and the Environment. In: New Frontiers in Environmental Constitutionalism, UNEP, May 2017,
Google Scholar

Knox, John ,2020, Constructing the Human Right to a Healthy Environment, Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 2020, Vol 16:1, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-lawsocsci-031720-074856
Google Scholar

Kobol-Benda, Vivien, 2022, The current status of the right to the environment at the global level, Opole Studies in Administration and Law (OSAP) Volume 19 Issue 4 June 2022,
Google Scholar

Kobylarz, Natalia, 2020, Overview of environmental case-law of the ECtHR, in: Human Rights for the Planet, Proceedings of the High-Level International Conference on Human Rights and Environmental Protection , Strasbourg, 5 October 2020 p 20, available at https://www.coe.int/en/web/human-rights-rule-of-law/human-rights-and-the-environment
Google Scholar

Kotzé, Luis, 2019, International Environmental Law’s Lack of Normative Ambition: an Opportunity for the Global Pact for the Environment?, Journal for European Environmental & Planning Law, Volume 16 (2019) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/18760104-01603002
Google Scholar

Krämer, Ludwig, 2012, EU Environmental Law, Sweet & Maxwell, 2012
Google Scholar

Krämer, Ludwig, 2020 r, Rights of Nature and Their Implementation, 17 Journal for European Environmental & Planning Law , Volume 17 (2020) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/18760104-01701005
Google Scholar

Kurki ,Visa, 2022, Can Nature Hold Rights? It’s Not as Easy as You Think, Transnational Environmental Law, 11:3 (2022), p 525 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S2047102522000358
Google Scholar

Ladeur,Karl-Heinz, 1996, Environmental Constitutional Law. In: European Environmental Law. A Comparative Perspective, G.Winter(ed) ,Dartmouth Publ, 1996
Google Scholar

Lambert, Elisabeth, The Environment and Human Rights. Introductory Report to the High-Level Conference Environmental Protection and Human Rights, Strasbourg, 27 February 2020, p 16, available at https://rm.coe.int/report-e-lambert-en/16809c827f
Google Scholar

Lawrysen, Luc, 2009 An Introduction to the Aarhus Convention, paper presented at International Conference on the Practical Implementation of the Aarhus Convention, Brno, 16-17 April 2009, p 1, available at https://www.eufje.org/images/DocAarhus/Brno%202009%20Lavrysen.pdf
Google Scholar

Lavrysen, Luc. 2010 “The Aarhus Convention: Between Environmental Protection and Human Rights.” Liège, Strasbourg, Bruxelles: Parcours Des Droits de l’homme., Anthemis, 2010,
Google Scholar

Lawrysen, Luc, 2012 -1 The Fundamental Right to the Protection of a Healthy Environment, in: Advancing Justice, Governance and Law for Environmental Sustainability, UNEP 2012,
Google Scholar

https://wedocs.unep.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.11822/9969/advancing_justice_governance_law.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
Google Scholar

Lawrysen,,Luc, 2012-2, The Right to the Protection of a Healthy Environment, Proceedings. World Congress on Justice, Governance and Law for Environmental Sustainability – Rio de
Google Scholar

Janeiro 17-20 June 2012, p 2, available at https://biblio.ugent.be/publication/2917157
Google Scholar

Lawrysen, Luc and Theunis, Jan, 2007, The Right to the Protection of a Healthy Environment in the Belgian Constitution: retrospect and international perspective (in: ) Constitutional rights to an ecologically balanced environment, I. Larmuseau (ed), V.VO.R 2007
Google Scholar

Lozano, Carlos, 2023, Animal Rights in Colombia: A Critique from an Environmental Perspective, Revista Derecho del Estado n.º 54, enero-abril de 2023
Google Scholar

Pedersen, Olle, 2008, European Environmental Human Rights and Environmental Rights: A Long Time Coming?, 21 The Geo. Int'l Envtl. L.Rev 2008, Nr 73,
Google Scholar

Pedersen, Olle, 2010, The Ties that Bind: The Environment, the European Convention on Human Rights and the Rule of Law, European Public Law 2010, Vol. 16, Nr 4. DOI: https://doi.org/10.54648/EURO2010040
Google Scholar

Manual on Human Rights and the Environment, Council of Europe, 3rd edition, 2022
Google Scholar

Morrow, Karen, 2017, New Frontiers:Europe, Human Rights and the Environment In: New Frontiers in Environmental Constitutionalism, UNEP, May 2017
Google Scholar

Pallemaerts , marc, 2011, Introduction . In: The Aarhus convention at Ten: Interactions and Tensions between
Google Scholar

Conventional International Law and EU Environmental Law, Pallemaerts, M. (ed.), Europa Law Publishing, Groningen, 2011
Google Scholar

Pediaditaki, Tonia, 2007,The right to the protection of the environment in the Greek Constitution. In: Constitutional rights to an ecologically balanced environment, I. Larmuseau (ed), V.VO.R 2007,
Google Scholar

Rivero Godoy, Juan, 2017, The relationship between environmental and human rights protection under regional law in Latin America. In: New Frontiers in Environmental Constitutionalism. UNEP 2017
Google Scholar

Sands, Philippe, 1995, Principles of International Environmental Law, Manchester University Press, 1995
Google Scholar

Sands, Philippe,2012, Principles of International Environmental Law, 2nd edition, Cambridge University Press, 2012
Google Scholar

Schoukens, Hendrik, 2020, Rights of Nature in the European Union: Contemplating the Operationalization of an Eco-Centric Concept in an Anthropocentric Environment? In: Non-Human Nature in World Politics. Theory and Practice, J. Castro Pereira and A. Saramago (eds), Springer 2020, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-49496-4_11
Google Scholar

Sohn, Luis, 1973, The Stockholm Declaration on the Human Environment, Harward International Law Journal, Volume 14, No3, Summer 1973,
Google Scholar

Steiger at al,1980, Steiger, B. Demel, H. G. Fey, P. Malanczuk, The Fundamental Right to a Decent Environment. In: Trends in Environmental Law and Policy, ed. by M. Bothe, Gland 1980
Google Scholar

Stone, Christopher, 1972, Should Trees Have Standing. Toward Legal Right for Natural Objects, Southern California Law Review 1972, No. 45
Google Scholar

Sunkin Maurice, Ong, David and Wight, Robert, 2002, Sourcebook on Environmental Laws, 2nd edition, Cavendish, London 2002 ,
Google Scholar

Vasak, Karel, 1977, A 30-year struggle; the sustained efforts to give force of law to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The UNESCO Courier: a window open on the world November 1977,
Google Scholar

Vallejo Galárraga , Santiago, 2018, Recognition of Rights of Nature, as a Subject of Law, in the International Environmental Law Framework. In: J.Jendrośka and M. Bar (eds)
Google Scholar

Procedural Environmental Rights: Principle X in Theory and Practice (Intersentia, 2018)
Google Scholar

Villavicencio Calzadilla, Paola and Kotzé, Louis, Environmental constitutionalism and the ecocentric rights paradigm: the rights of nature in Ecuador and Bolivia. In: New Frontiers in Environmental Constitutionalism, UNEP, May 2017
Google Scholar