Nietzscheańskie tropy w Römerbrief Karla Bartha

Adam R. Prokop

doi:10.25167/so.3310

Published: 2015-12-31

Vol. 15 (2015)

Nietzschean Traces in Römerbrief (1922) by Karl Barth

Adam R. Prokop

Studia Oecumenica

Section: Articles

https://doi.org/10.25167/so.3310

Abstract

The article examines the influence of Friedrich Nietzsche’s thought on the second edition of Karl Barth’s commentary on the Epistle to the Romans from 1922. The paper concentrates on direct quotations and references by name to the philosopher in the work discussed. All quotes are presented, analysed and compared with the source text. Subsequently, the similarities and differences in terms of the contents between the interpretation of the theologian and the philosophy adopted by him are outlined. The results can be divided into three thematic groups. The first relates to the criticism of the historical thought and ahistorical concept in which Barth’s understanding of faith is immersed. The second revolves around the human being: its condition and position according to K. Barth exhibit, despite completely different teleology, astonishing similarities to Nietzschean anthropology. The third group concerns severe criticism of religion, which in Römerbrief is not only appreciated, but also almost completely assumed. Finally, further possible steps are outlined for the examination of the effects caused by the adoption of F. Nietzsche’s philosophy on K. Barth’s work.

Keywords:

K. Barth, F. Nietzsche, Epistle to the Romans, criticism of religion

Download files

pdf (Język Polski)

Citation rules

Prokop, A. R. (2015). Nietzschean Traces in Römerbrief (1922) by Karl Barth. Studia Oecumenica, 15, 203–217. https://doi.org/10.25167/so.3310

Cited by / Share

References

Barth K., Kunde von unbekannten Gott, „Der Spiegel” (1959) nr 52, 69–81.
Google Scholar

Barth K., Römerbrief. Zweite Fassung (1922), Zürich 201219.
Google Scholar

Guja J., Koncepcja wiary w „Römerbrief” Karla Bartha, Kraków 2009.
Google Scholar

Härle W., Barth Karl, w: Lexikon für Theologie und Kirche, t. 2, Freiburg im Br. – Basel – Rom – Wien 19943, 35.
Google Scholar

T. Kleffmann, Nietzsches Begriff des Lebens und die evangelische Theologie, Tübingen 2003.
Google Scholar

P. Köster, Nietzsche-Kritik und Nietzsche-Rezeption in der Theologie des 20. Jahrhunderts, „Nietzsche-Studien“ 10–11 (1981–1982), 615–685.
Google Scholar

F. Nietzsche, Ausgewählte Werke. Menschliches – Allzumenschliches. Also sprach Zaratusthra. Jenseits von Gut und Böse, red. A. Ulfig, Köln 2000.
Google Scholar

F. Nietzsche, Werke in drei Bänden, red. K. Schlechta, München 1954.
Google Scholar

A. Nossol, Chrystologia Karola Bartha, Lublin 1979.
Google Scholar

N. Peter, Karl Barth als Leser und Interpret Nietzsches, „Journal for the History of Modern Theology / Zeitschrift für Neuere Theologiegeschichte“ 1 (1994), 251–264.
Google Scholar

W. Tatarkiewicz, Historia filozofii, Warszawa 199914.
Google Scholar

U. Willers, Friedrich Nietzsches antichristliche Christologie. Eine theologische Rekonstruktion, Innsbruck – Wien 1988.
Google Scholar

K. M. Wolsza, Religijne wymiary doświadczenia i myślenia, Opole 2011.
Google Scholar